The Cotuit Fire District is a separate body from the Town of Barnstable. It runs the village's fire department and its public water supply, and its budget also covers Freedom Hall, the village street lights, the Cotuit Library and the historical society. Its FY2026 residential rate is $2.07 per $1,000 of assessed value, close to double the $1.15 charged by the district that covers Osterville and Centerville. Set next to the rest of Barnstable, that gap has a different explanation than spending.
The five district rates
The town's FY2026 rate sheet lists Barnstable's residential rate at $6.80 per $1,000, along with a separate rate for each of the town's five fire districts.
| Fire district | FY2026 residential rate per $1,000 |
|---|---|
| Centerville-Osterville-Marstons Mills | $1.15 |
| Cotuit | $2.07 |
| Hyannis | $2.40 |
| West Barnstable | $2.66 |
| Barnstable | $2.81 |
Cotuit's rate is the second-lowest of the five. The Hyannis, West Barnstable and Barnstable Village districts all charge more. The one that stands apart is COMM, the Centerville-Osterville-Marstons Mills Fire District, at roughly half of any other district's rate. A buyer weighing Cotuit against Osterville is comparing against the town's outlier.
Why COMM's rate is low
The two districts differ far more in the amount of property behind each budget than in how much they spend.
The Cotuit Fire District's FY2027 budget, in the treasurer's September 2026 report, plans to raise $4,866,357 in current-year taxes. COMM's FY2027 warrant, taken up at its May 19, 2026 annual meeting, put about $17.3 million of tax-funded articles before voters across Prudential Committee operations, fire operations, information systems and staffing. COMM asks its taxpayers for more than three times what Cotuit does.
COMM still ends up with the lower rate. Dividing each tax figure by the district's FY2026 rate gives a rough sense of the property behind it: about $2.35 billion of assessed value in Cotuit and about $15 billion across Centerville, Osterville and Marstons Mills. The estimate is approximate because it pairs FY2027 budgets with FY2026 rates, but the ratio holds. COMM's property base is roughly six times Cotuit's, while its proposed fire operating budget of $10,555,815.72 is about three times Cotuit's. Cotuit's higher rate reflects the size of the village more than its spending.
What the Cotuit levy buys
According to the treasurer's September 2026 report, the district's FY2027 general fund budgets $3,153,478 for the fire department and $1,137,300 for benefits. Prudential Committee administration gets $518,544. The same budget includes smaller lines most buyers would not expect from a fire district. Freedom Hall gets $28,939, street lights $11,131, and the library and historical line $42,411. The committed-cash schedule breaks that last figure into $28,411 for the Cotuit Library and $14,000 for the historical society.
The water department mostly pays for itself. Its FY2027 expenditure budget is $1,028,853, against $1,030,000 budgeted from water rates and meter fees. COMM's warrant funds its water department the same way, from water department income. Both districts run their own water, so water does not explain the gap between their rates.
Cotuit's water capital work for FY2027 is listed in the same report. The debt-funded articles are $500,000 for water main replacement, $80,000 for well cleaning and rehabilitation, $20,000 for lime tank work and $57,200 for cybersecurity upgrades. A replacement generator gets $111,000 in cash. The district's water department page carries current notices and the rate schedule.
The station on High Street enters the budget
The largest line on the district's capital books is on High Street. The Cotuit Fire District is building an addition to and renovation of its station at 64 High Street, combining that parcel with 56 High Street next door. Voters approved $1.3 million for design at the May 29, 2024 annual district meeting, as the Cotuit-Santuit Civic Association reported. Construction funding followed at the May 2025 meeting, and a regional fire station tracker listed site preparation beginning in December 2025 with construction under way by September 2026.
The station reaches the budget through its financing. The September 2026 treasurer's report carries $11,653,187 for station construction, of which $1,763,724 had been spent. Its FY2027 budget includes $669,632 in debt service, a line with no FY2026 amount beside it. At its October 14, 2026 meeting, the Prudential Committee discussed refinancing a $12 million bond anticipation note due December 4, 2026, weighing different mixes of long-term bonds and short-term notes.
For anyone pricing a Cotuit home over the next several years, the FY2026 district rate is a starting point. The Prudential Committee's posted minutes and the treasurer's monthly reports are where the bond terms will appear once they are set.
COMM has capital plans of its own. Its FY2027 warrant included $402,944 to design an iron and manganese treatment facility at the Hayden wellfield and $818,368.98 for work to remove emerging contaminants from its water supply, drawn from PFAS settlement funds, water surplus and earlier article balances. It also proposed moving $750,000 of free cash into a stabilization fund for future pumpers and a ladder truck, and borrowing $476,600 for a replacement ambulance. Both districts are investing, and COMM's larger base spreads each dollar it borrows across more property.
Rates and houses
Two homes at the same asking price can carry different assessments, so a district rate on its own says less about a specific house than it seems to. A Cotuit cottage and a Centerville colonial listed at the same number may not be assessed alike. The district rate matters most when two specific houses are on the table, and much less when the choice is between villages in general.
The rates and budget figures here come from published town and district records and are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm the figures for any specific property with the Barnstable assessor's office or your own tax professional.
If you are weighing a Cotuit home against one in Osterville or Centerville, Colleen and Sabrina Riley are glad to talk through what each house costs to carry. If you already own in Cotuit, start with a free home valuation.